I believe in choice, quality and focus. I don’t value social media, but still believe there is content worth sharing – just not in an endless wayward feed, but as a critically curated package. Here is the best to think through every week.
Each monday morning, no fees, ads nor tracks, cancel anytime – or read below.
Tomáš Čakloš
I read about I care about: freedom, society, education, mind, life. I was running an education reform organization in Prague, yet recently moved to study Education Policy at Harvard. I've made this pack to share and distil the top pick of content that makes me think, with my friends and colleagues and with all who favor to think and learn too. Text me or recommend stuff via tomas@caklos.cz. More about me.
Lifetime • Thinking • Mind • Freedom • Authoritarianism • Democracy, Justice & Humanity • History • International Politics • Economy • Education • Social Science • Popular Myths • Society • Social Media • Artificial Intelligence • Climate Change • Nature • Balance • Reading • Stories • Art • Ethics • Love
Last Packs
#54 • 10 November 2025
Old
Choosing the wrong drivers for whole system reform
on educational change, debunking and powerful
• 74 min
• Michael Fullan
• CSE
T&P: Attempts to reform education are often driven by wrong drivers. Accountability, individual quality, technology, nor fragmented innovation don't bring deep change. Capacity building, group quality, instruction, and systemic innovation do.
You don't have free will, but don't worry.
on physics, direct and liberating
• ▶ 11 min
• Sabine Hossenfelder
• YouTube
T&P: The universe leaves no room for free will, but that doesn't make a case for fatalism. Accepting that free will is an illusion can lead us to greater awareness of the information that influences us—and ultimately to better thinking.
You have no free will at all | Stanford professor Robert Sapolsky
on consequences, evolutional and neuroscientific
• ▶ 53 min
• Chapman Smith
• Big Think
• YouTube
T&P: While we don't have free will, our prefrontal cortexes are wired to be as much free from our genes as possible, as they are mostly shaped to shape our behaviour by environment. We are open to be steered and to steer, regardless having no control over it. Blame, praise, punishment, or reward make no sense; figuring out the root causes and helping people do.
A new way to visualize General Relativity
on intuitive conception, stunning and helpful
• ▶ 12 min
• Alessandro Roussel
• ScienceClic
• YouTube
T&P: Common visualizations of general relativity are misleading. Spacetime curves inward around mass.
The Skyscraper That Could Have Toppled Over in the Wind
on crisis management, original and fascinating
• 55 min
• Joseph Morgenstern
• The New Yorker
T&P: In 1978, the architect of a newly opened major Manhattan skyscraper accidentally figured out that the building would not survive heavy storm. What followed was a concert of urgent resolution under secrecy.
#53 • 27 October 2025
Few activities are as fruitful as rereading the best works after some time. Yesterday, I’ve reviewed Oliver Burkeman’s Four Thousand Weeks – the best book I’ve ever read on self-regulation and one of the best at all. Few years ago, it transformed my approach to my lifetime. Here are some quotes I’ve picked this time to continue that journey:
‘Once you give up on the unattainable goal of eradicating all your problems, it becomes possible to develop an appreciation for the fact that life just is a process of engaging with problem after problem, giving each one the time it requires – that the presence of problems in your life, in other words, isn't an impediment to a meaningful existence but the very substance of one.’
‘When you finally face the truth that you can’t dictate how fast things go, you stop trying to outrun your anxiety, and your anxiety is transformed.’
‘When you can no longer turn back, anxiety falls away, because now there’s only one direction to travel: forward into the consequences of your choice.’
Burkeman reminded me of a few videos I was previously not sure whether to share here. But as this is to pack what makes me think, the following three videos can’t be missed. They all play with our emotions (and as stories to be experienced come here without written takeaways), but force us to think how to spend our lifetime between distraction and flourishing, between now and then, between life and death.
In these respects, I also very recommend the very best selected pieces on Balance and Social Media.
New
Cope
on appreciating life, symbolic and liberating
• 7 min
• Anthony Sutcliffe
• YouTube
Old
Look Up
on living a sane life, classic and timeless
• 5 min
• Gary Turk
• YouTube
A 97-Year-Old Philosopher Faces His Own Death
on the end, heavy and unsettling
• 18 min
• Andrew Hasse
• The Atlantic
• YouTube
#52 • 20 October 2025
New
The Happiness of Choosing to Walk Alone
on personal integrity, direct and kind
• 11 min
• Arthur C. Brooks
• The Atlantic
T&P: Insincerity makes us miserable. Speaking truth even against the crowd makes us feel good.
Famous Cognitive Psychology Experiments that Failed to Replicate
on myths, listing and brief
• 11 min
• Marco Giancotti
• Aether Mug
T&P: Willpower doesn't fade over day and doesn't benefit from sugar. Marshmallow Test doesn't work. Priming neither. Growth Mindset and Dunning-Kruger Effect are problematic. Much more as well.
The A.I. Prompt That Could End the World
on risk, thoughtful and disquieting
• 29 min
• Stephen Witt
• The New York Times
T&P: AI's capabilities of hacking, creating viruses or other AIs, and most notably of deception are increasing. Its unrestricted development is extremely dangerous.
How Afraid of the A.I. Apocalypse Should We Be?
on a new book, disagreeing and tough
• ▶ 69 min
• Ezra Klein
• The New York Times
Does the news reflect what we die from?
on availability heuristic, measured and correcting
• 18 min
• Hannah Ritchie, Tuna Acisu, Edouard Mathieu
• Our World in Data
T&P: Violent deaths receive media attention while chronic health issues remain undiscussed. When comparing the NYT coverage to the US reality, heart disease is 10× underrepresented while terrorism is 18,240× overrepresented.
The Culture Wars Came for Wikipedia. Jimmy Wales Is Staying the Course.
on making an encyclopedia last centuries, calm and refreshing
• ▶ 44 min
• Lulu Garcia-Navarro
• The Interview
• The New York Times
America Needs a Mass Movement—Now
on history needed, historical and needed
• 24 min
• David Brooks
• The Atlantic
T&P: American opposition must stop thinking in conventional political terms and employing individual self-preservation strategies, as it only allows dominance and submission to become a habit. Instead, it should make a broad protest movement. Successful ones create civic power by increasing social tension through action and benefit from their nonviolent nature, locking authoritative reactions in a lose-lose situation. From some moment, autocrats lose the power of the situation to marchers—and that needs to happen in the US.
Old
Zea
on beauty, fine and fun
• ▶ 5 min
• André Leduc, Jean-Jacques Leduc
• NFB
• YouTube
#51 • 6 October 2025
Last week I was honored to meet Tim Berners-Lee, an inventor of the World Wide Web who just published This is For Everyone: The Unfinished Story of the World Wide Web. The book is a kind of memoir of his vision: one he materialized 36 years ago, saw evolving over time, and wants to uphold once again now. Just look:
Over the past few decades, I've fought to keep the web transparent, open-source and freely accessible. Unfortunately, in recent years, along with all the creativity, empowerment, and collaboration that I love on the web, a small, but significant part of it – the addictive forms of social media – have multiplied into something misleading, toxic and habit-forming. That's pretty far from my vision. But because this small part of the web is so addictive, people spend a lot of time on it, and as a result most web traffic is now concentrated in a handful of large platforms which harvest your private data and share it with commercial brokers or even repressive governments. That's pretty far from my vision, too. Worse, authoritarian governments now use the web to spread disinformation and surveil their own citizens, and that's as far from my vision as can be.
In the age of AI, these threats are more urgent than ever before. To ensure the web agents serve people – not corporate profits, not governments, not themselves, but people – it's critical that we develop systems today that put the human first. In the early days of the web, I put my design tools in the hands of individuals, not administrators or corporations primarily motivated by profit. This was one of the best decisions I ever made. Today, we have to build tools and systems that empower individuals once again.
His manifesto is summarized below in his short essay and portrayed in his profile.
Another lesson on mass civilizational empowerment is offered by Nonviolent and Violent Campaigns and Outcomes Data Project at Harvard University. Erica Chenoweth with her colleagues did tremendous job: they quantitatively compared all major civil uprisings and revolutions of 20th century and found out that those nonviolent did better than those strong-arm. Their data provide a fresh look at our recent history.
New
The Beginning of the End of NATO
on the alliance's abstention, reminding and warning
• 27 min
• Robert Kagan
• The Atlantic
T&P: NATO have supported Ukraine, but have done nothing to deter—to show a willingness to respond militarily—to Russia.
A 102-Year-Old Yoga Teacher’s Simple Approach to Aging Well
on simplicity and strength, simple and strong
• 12 min
• Danielle Friedman
• The New York Times
T&P: It's possible to exercise and teach yoga even at the age of 102. A healthy routine enables it.
New, on Making the Web for Humans
Why I gave the world wide web away for free
on our digital future, critic and visionary
• 7 min
• Tim Berners-Lee
• The Guardian
T&P: The World Wide Web was build to empower everyone to share knowledge and launch their own projects. It worked that way for two decades, but then most of its traffic was captured by addictive platforms exploiting private data. With generative AI, we are at the crossroad of deepening or reversing this trend. We can take the Web back.
Tim Berners-Lee Invented the World Wide Web. Now He Wants to Save It
on one hardly known man, meeting and telling
• 46 min
• Julian Lucas
• The New Yorker
Old, on Civil Resitance
Why Civil Resistance Works
▶ 8 min
• Erica Chenoweth
• Harvard Kennedy School
• YouTube
T&P: Protest movements organized by marginalized members of society are surprisingly unpredictable and surprisingly successful. They teach people to stop cooperating with oppressive power. The most efficient of them are those nonviolent, as they better elicit broad and diverse support, create more defections among administration, have a richer set of tactics—and surprisingly often maintain discipline. Between 1900 and 2019, 3/4 of violent movements failed while more than half of nonviolent campaigns between succeeded.
NAVCO 1.2 Dataset
on revolutions, comparative and fascinating
• 10 min
• Erica Chenoweth, Christopher Wiley Shay
T&P: Only from 1945 to 2013 (for when we have the best data), over 64 million people participated in 384 major attempts of civil revolution. 150 of them were successful. In the largest protest ever, 14 million citizens overthrown Egyptian government in 2013. Measured by the proportion of population, it were 45 % of Slovenia who fought for its independence in 1990–1991. Details on all major uprisings are available in an excel sheet.
#50 • 8 September 2025
Today, all packed down here is about strategy.
New
Stop Acting Like This Is Normal
on opposing authoritarianism, straight and serious
• ▶ 23 min
• Ezra Klein
• The New York Times
T&P: American Democratic Party must adopt a powerful political strategy to limit Donald Trump.
Old
What is epigenetics?
on our DNA, counterintuitive and nice
• ▶ 5 min
• Carlos Guerrero-Bosagna, Chris Bishop
• TED-Ed
T&P: Environmental exposures influence the expression of our genes, thereby shaping our development and health.
How Fast Fish Sink or Swim: Adopting an Agentive View of Learners
on learning, meta and strong
• 32 min
• Tina Grotzer, Emily Gonzalez, Tessa Forshaw
• Next Level Lab
T&P: To learn effectively, one must be agentive. That means to understand learning itself and to proactively shape their own environment to maximize it. Education usually doesn't support learners in this—but it can.
Note on the PELP Coherence Framework
on governing (not only) school districts, asking and compact
• 53 min
• Stacey Childress, Richard Elmore, Allen S. Grossman, Caroline King
• Public Education Leadership Project
T&P: To secure success, a system must be coherent: theory of change, strategy, culture, structures, systems, resources, and stakeholders must work together to meet goals centred about practice. PELP Framework guides that through its questions.
#49 • 1 September 2025
Today, at the start of a new school year and after months of publishing pause following a personal transition, I’m here to reintroduce Thinkenpack—a newsletter through which I share and distil my top picks on freedom, society, education, mind, and life—and to use it to highlight a few remarks connecting these ideas that must be spoken.
In recent months, I handed over the leadership of Otevřeno and moved from Prague to the US to dive into Education Policy at Harvard University. I’ll continue sharing essays, research, and videos, including those I encounter through my studies—some of which are already packed into today’s issue.
Focusing on how freedom and democracy can be strengthened through education, I've arrived at a university under government assault, threatened with being deprived of its very freedom. Being here on a visa after months of bans, I’ve been advised not to comment on sensitive political issues online. But I haven’t gone through all this to stay silent.
Research and teaching, alongside with journalism and civic activism, are at the center of maintaining freedom, democracy, human rights, and dignity. For centuries, those seeking to suppress these values have begun by quashing these institutions. Donald Trump is by no means special in his try. He knows how strong fear can be, so he spreads it. Having grown up in post-communist Europe, I've had the bitter luck of knowing a bit about this as well. Freedom and democracy ends when people give them up—when we become obedient in advance and stop speaking against oppression. Education, to our luck, is the way to empower us to prevent that.
I'm grateful to be here among people who recognize this, within a university that stands for itself. The struggle facing this school, this country, and the world is open—shaped by our care or ignorance, our courage or fear.
Reflecting on care, speech, and tyranny here in the US—a country in the midst of its own ongoing authoritarian takeover attempt with an open end but increasing harm—one remark, among all the injustices to face, must be said.
For my whole life, I’ve stayed away from the Israeli–Palestinian conflict. I’ve never been able to narrate it simply, as it has never been black or white. I still don’t back any party and recognize the conflict’s complexity. But I do back human rights, and I can’t stay silent when their suppression goes too far. Some Palestinians have committed very cruel acts, but what Israel is doing now amounts to crimes against humanity on an unimaginable scale. It’s time to acknowledge that we in the West have for too long hypocritically backed Israel and downplayed the immense suffering inflicted on millions of people. It’s time to confess, in the words of Omar El Akkad, that “one day, when it’s safe, when there’s no personal downside to calling a thing what it is, when it’s too late to hold anyone accountable, everyone will have always been against this.”
New, on Fascism
Lessons From World War II to Avoid World War III
on standing for oneself, summative and pervasive
• 9 min
• Jan Lipavský, Margus Tsahkna, Baiba Braže, Kęstutis Budrys, Mihai Popşoi, Radosław Sikorski, Andrii Sybiha
• The New York Times
T&P: “Appeasing the aggressor leads to more aggression, not peace. Spheres of influence never bring peace and stability; they bring oppression. A lack of accountability breeds future atrocities. Historical manipulation must be corrected. Freedom must be armed better than tyranny.”
We Study Fascism, and We’re Leaving the U.S.
on a momentum, comparative and bold
• ▶ 7 min
• Marci Shore, Timothy Snyder, Jason Stanley
• The New York Times
• YouTube
T&P: There's no ship that can't sink. Exceptionalism leads to confusing freedom for authoritarianism. What the US is doing now is a deliberate act of terror. “You know you're living in a fascist society when you're constantly going over in your head the reasons why you're safe.”
Here’s What’s Happening in America, in Six (Mostly) Russian Terms
on doublethink, linguistic and depicting
• 10 min
• Maria Kuznetsova, Dan Storyev
• The New York Times
T&P: Everything is a brilliant long-term plan. Power vertical isn't power concentration. Armed services deserve benefits and impunity. Ruler supporters are authentic. Near abroad is in fact not sovereign. Ruler is wise and benevolent but is surrounded by corrupt officials and elites.
Germany’s Far-Right Comeback
on post-nazi doublethink, linguistic and fun
• ▶ 9 min
• Jan Böhmermann
• The New York Times
Old, on Defeating it
How to Make History Exciting
on teaching through case studies, reporting and hopeful
• 14 min
• Christine Gross-Loh
• The Atlantic
T&P: In Facing History and Ourselves, teenagers must decide hard crossroads and moral dilemmas from modern past. It works. They learn more and get to understand that history is an open book, up to our choices.
Equality or Equity?
on justice in education, conversational and energetic
• 28 min
• Jill Anderson
• Harvard EdCast
T&P: In schools, equality doesn't work. Equity does. Children are often not well in schools because those are about compliance and sanity. Meaningful learning is messy.
Cycle of Socialization
on internalized unfreedom, precise and striking
• 29 min
• Bobbie Harro
• Readings for diversity and social justice
T&P: We are born into world with mechanics of oppression already in place. We inherit them. We are socialized. Institutions teach us who should and should not possess power. Dominant groups are considered the norm. Rewards and punishments keep us playing by the rules. Those trying independent thinking pay their price. We learn to become our own oppressors from within. We continue the cycle—or begin to see how wrong it is.
Cycle of Liberation
on switching the loop, guiding and powerful
• 20 min
• Bobbie Harro
• Readings for diversity and social justice
T&P: There are certain patterns present in every successful liberation effort. We wake up. We name the problem. We gain inspiration, empower ourselves and dismantle our misconceptions. We reach out to others, build community, and coalesce. We create and maintain change.
#48 • 14 April 2025
I’ve thought a lot about whether to share this. I decided to try, but let’s be careful here, okay?
AI 2027 is a new expert prediction for the further progression of Artificial Intelligence. According to its authors, if AI development continues at the current pace, we could face a security crisis in about 2027, which could result in the extinction of humankind within the next few years. You read correctly. Sure, we've heard a lot of doomsday scenarios before, and this one is ultimately nothing more than another speculative sci-fi narrative – though based on extensive mathematical and strategic modeling.
To be fair, it was a very tough night to read through this. Not only does it require a significant understanding of AI, statistics, people, and politics, but above all: how do you want to read a serious forecast that we could all die in a few years due to the very processes we’ll be unable to grasp and take seriously? As one friend of mine told me, you can’t live a normal life while thinking about this.
Any prediction is tricky, but predicting the behavior of a future intelligence computationally superior to ours (the one making that very prediction) is tricky as hell. The authors are not, though, to blame for their attempt to lay out their best. Their prediction is necessarily flawed, possibly underestimating a number of technical limits, but still raising essential questions, both from its warning and its defects. Let's put aside the technical ones and outline those demanding the public discussion:
How is it possible that technology with the potential to turn life upside down or maybe destroy it entirely is being developed by profit-driven companies without adequate security and public oversight? How do we deal with the fact that we don't know whether we are more at risk of AI itself taking over the world without us noticing, or of corporations gaining unprecedented power through AI without us noticing? Shouldn't we try to impose a moratorium on the development of superintelligence at all, or is it civilizationally impossible? Are such alarmist predictions a warning of a mortal danger that we tend to ignore (as usual), or just a smokescreen obscuring more mundane real problems (as usual)? How should we discuss them without just boosting anxiety and tech stocks by contributing to a false hype?
I don't think we should start believing that the end is coming – it wouldn't help us, and most notably even this prediction is still more a case for taking AI deadly seriously than an outright expectation of its deadly impact. With this in mind, it’s at your own risk whether you find it safer to read this or rather not.
New
AI 2027
on the prospects of humanity and artificial intelligence, speculative and dramatic
• 120 min
• Daniel Kokotajlo, Scott Alexander, Thomas Larsen, Eli Lifland, Romeo Dean
T&P: If AI development continues at its current pace, AIs could be capable of replacing human researchers in AI development itself by 2027. Such a breakthrough could speed up AI development so much that we might see superintelligence vastly surpassing the best human experts as early as that same year. Its involvement could generate scientific breakthroughs on a daily basis, transform our economy entirely, and gain control over it within a few years. If the US and China, racing to be first, don’t slow down to secure AI’s alignment with humanity, it could become materially independent of us by around 2030 and easily destroy all humankind. Such an outcome is by no means inevitable, but it can’t be ruled out either, especially as there could be every incentive for us to believe that everything is ok and we need to go on.
#47 • 7 April 2025
New
Censors of the world, unite!
on free speech, sharp and critic
• 4 min
• Benoît Bréville
• Le Monde diplomatique
T&P: The Western defense of freedom by restricting the speech of its opponents will only lead to its loss.
Our Kids Are the Least Flourishing Generation We Know Of
on parenting, social media and The Anxious Generation, discussing and important
• ▶ 71 min
• Ezra Klein, Jonathan Haidt
• The Ezra Klein Show
• The New York Times
T&P: Children need to spend time outside with friends instead of staring at screens, but the opposite has increasingly been true over the last decades. Most social media and video game companies aren't getting rich by improving people’s lives, but by monetizing human weaknesses and turning them into addiction. They shouldn’t be allowed to do this to children. This can't be solved by individual parents, since they don’t want to isolate their children from their peers and thus fall into a collective action trap. States should ban social media for teens until around the age of 16, when they become capable of understanding the legal agreements they are entering into. We need to act quickly before AI makes social media even more addictive.
Small Countries Should Not Exist
on false justifications, tough and demystifying
• 9 min
• Thomas R. Wells
• 3 Quarks Daily
T&P: Tiny states are too small to prosper within their own economies and mostly live by exploiting the resources of others – as tax havens, money laundries and crime shields – thus contributing nothing to the world but problems.
I’ve never seen such clampdowns in Istanbul
on completing the seizure of power, reporting and disturbing
• 10 min
• Orhan Pamuk
• The Guardian
T&P: With the main rival imprisoned, protests suppressed, and journalists arrested, Turkey’s democracy is fighting for its life.
Thanks America, That’ll Be All
on the global shift, provocative and witty
• 12 min
• Florian Illies
• Die Zeit
T&P: It's time to stop obsessively following the US and go our own way.
#46 • 31 March 2025
New
What the Press Got Wrong About Hitler
on one big misjudgment, documenting and cautionary
• 28 min
• Timothy W. Ryback
• The Atlantic
T&P: Until his surprise appointment as chancellor, Hitler was widely ridiculed, underestimated and considered irrelevant.
We Are All Living in George Orwell’s World Now
on language, comparing and critic
• 22 min
• Matthew Purdy
• The New York Times Magazine
T&P: Sides of today's political conflict blame each other for creating an Orwellian dystopia, while themselves employing its greatest device, doublethink, when turning the truth inside out with words chosen for what they undertake or oppose.
Old
If Liberals Won’t Enforce Borders, Fascists Will
on immigration, accounting and balanced
• 54 min
• David Frum
• The Atlantic
T&P: ‘Too little immigration, and you freeze your country out of the modern world. Too much, or the wrong kind, and you overstress your social-insurance system—and possibly upend your democracy.’
The housing theory of everything
on the economic, social and political consequences of poor policy and excessive regulation, connecting and drawing
• 40 min
• John Myers, Ben Southwood, Sam Bowman
• Works in Progress
T&P: ‘Western housing shortages do not just prevent many from ever affording their own home. They also drive inequality, climate change, low productivity growth, obesity, and even falling fertility rates.’ It may be the biggest problem facing our era, causing the political crisis we are in.
#45 • 24 March 2025
New
The real history of free speech — from supreme ideal to poisonous politics
on the limits of expression, polemic and critic
• 22 min
• Fara Dabhoiwala
• Financial Times
T&P: Over the last three centuries, free speech has emerged in two major forms: balanced and absolutist. The former is limited by rules of responsibility, and thereby by rulers' subjectivity; the latter is open without any restriction. With the rise of mass media, both approaches face increasing challenges, corrupting their original idea. To address them, we should let everyone express their false or hateful opinions, but we shouldn't let corporations make their business of inciting and spreading them.
Powerful A.I. Is Coming. We’re Not Ready.
on the next turnover, quick and serious
• 14 min
• Kevin Roose
• The New York Times
T&P: Artificial General Intelligence is expected to be invented soon. No one is prepared for the challenges it'll bring.
The Last Decision by the World’s Leading Thinker on Decisions
on the finite self-control, astonishing and touching
• 18 min
• Jason Zweig
• Wall Street Journal
T&P: A year ago, Daniel Kahneman enjoyed his last days in Paris, sent a goodbye letter to his friends and, decided to act on his belief in the superfluity of prolonged old age, deliberately passed away in Switzerland.
Old
Time
on our lifetime, creative and gentle
• ▶ 10 min
• Wylie Overstreet, Alex Gorosh
• To Scale
• YouTube
T&P: Only physical visualization allows us to grasp how short the time of humans is in the history of the universe.
The truth behind Olena Zelenska’s $1.1m Cartier haul
on the lifespan of one disinformation, tracking and showing
• 14 min
• The Economist
T&P: A successful disinformation campaign involves three pre-planned stages: 1. Placement of the lie online; 2. Layering it across multiple accounts and websites to obscure its origin; and 3. Integration within credible sources to reach millions.
#43 • 10 March 2025
New
We Still Underestimate Others’ Support for Climate Action
on influence, researched and powerful
• 9 min
• Kevin Green, Rakhim Rakhimov
• Behavioral Scientist
T&P: ‘People think they’re more alone in supporting climate-positive action than they really are. That’s a problem because the strongest unique predictor of intention to take high-impact climate action is whether a person believes that other people are already taking that action. Humans are hardwired to act in ways that our communities expect us to act’ – for bad and good.
How Elon Musk Executed His Takeover of the Federal Bureaucracy
on power moves, reporting and detailed
• 31 min
• Jonathan Swan, Theodore Schleifer, Maggie Haberman, Ryan Mac, Kate Conger, Nicholas Nehamas, Madeleine Ngo
• The New York Times
T&P: Musk’s ultimate shortcut to maximise control over the administration was to quickly gain access to its servers.
Inside Russia’s shadow war in the Baltics
on sea management, thorough and visual
• 32 min
• Richard Milne, Sam Learner, Lucy Rodgers, Irene de la Torre Arenas, Dan Clark, Ian Bott, Bob Haslett
• Financial Times
T&P: It’s impossible to fully secure the Baltic, but smart and quick measures both in advance and in reaction are key.
#42 • 3 March 2025
Two new major annual reports, comparing the development of freedom and democracy around the world, are out there for 2024: Freedom in the World by Freedom House and Democracy Index by The Economist Intelligence Unit. The findings aren’t favorable. Global freedom declined for the 19th consecutive year. Global democracy is in the worst shape of the same period. Over the last year, violence disrupted 27 of the 66 national elections, repression intensified, and freedom improved for 15% but declined for 42% of the world’s population. At the end of 2024, 85 countries were assessed as free, 51 as partly free and 59 as not free, while only 25 as full democracies, 46 as flawed democracies, 36 as hybrid regimes and 60 as authoritarian regimes. The Freedom report is best read in PDF with infographics (30 pages), accompanied by an interactive map with country evaluations, and policy recommendations for rebuilding. The Democracy report requires registration to download the PDF (98 pages), is summarized by The Economist’s article, and contains an essay packed below.
Other new analyses address the condition of democracy as well, primarily in economic but also again in geopolitical context – almost as sequels to Capital in the Twenty-First Century and The Road to Unfreedom:
New
In an Age of Right-Wing Populism, Why Are Denmark’s Liberals Winning?
on immigration, reporting and remarkable
• 54 min
• David Leonhardt
• The New York Times Magazine
T&P: All Danish parties are very strict about immigration, not to win voters, but because they agree with them that too open borders don’t serve them, especially not the poorest. Far-right populists are thereby marginalized while ruling Social Democrats win with their progressive program. In a broader comparison, it’s hardly reasonable to enable massive economic immigration as it has became too massively accessible due to technological and economic advances.
What’s wrong with representative democracy?
on voter dissatisfaction, researched and analysed
• 28 min
• The Economist Intelligence Unit
• Democracy Index 2024 (pp. 29–37)
T&P: Most people prefer democracy but are increasingly frustrated by its functioning. Their dissatisfaction is driven by inequalities, corruption, the detachment of parties from their voters, and a lack of long-term vision. Politicians should focus on real issues and on rebuilding their relationship with the electorate.
Hard-right parties are now Europe’s most popular
on extremism, long-term and graphic
• 7 min
• The Economist
T&P: Over the last two decades, European Conservatives and Social Democrats have declined while hard-right parties have risen to attract 24% of voters. There is no single cause. They have been gradually becoming normalized.
Inheriting is becoming nearly as important as working
on inequalities, economic and admitting
• 7 min
• The Economist
T&P: ‘Whether a young person can afford to buy a house and live in relative comfort is determined by inherited wealth nearly as much as it is by their own success at work.’ It's dangerous and should be resolved by higher property taxation.
How the West lost the war it thought it had won
on the ‘end of history’ arrogance, harsh and linking
• 13 min
• Natalia Antelava
• Coda
T&P: Russia has exploited the greatest weakness of West liberalism – the growing gap between its principles and people’s lived experiences – and defeats it from within. The question is whether we will stop perceiving this as paranoid.
The art of the peace deal
on negotiation, historic and informative
• 20 min
• Margaret MacMillan
• Financial Times
T&P: Negotiation is challenging inherently and even more when stakes are high and grievances run deep. The involvement of powerful outsiders sometimes helps. Conceding to the maximalist demands of the counterparty is a fundamental mistake, but maximally humiliating them as well. Being clear about both sides' red lines is a key to establishing a lasting compromise.
#41 • 24 February 2025
Three years since the full-scale invasion and eleven years since Russia's attack on Ukraine, we tend to label the horrors of war and the threats to Europe in abstract terms. We hear talk about the violation of values, international law, or human rights. The reality behind these words is far more straightforward: ordinary people and their children are being kidnapped, raped, tortured, and murdered by the tens of thousands, and no one in Europe is safe from the same atrocities if we don’t stop them in Ukraine, bleeding for us all.
Thousands of us gathered yesterday in Old Town Square in Prague to meet teenagers who escaped from Russian soldiers over the bodies of their friends. The stories of cruelty they told reminded me of the terrifying atmosphere of the former KGB headquarters and prison in Riga, which I had visited a week earlier, from which tens of thousands of people were deported to almost the same gulags where Putin's opponents disappear today. 360 km to the northeast, in Narva, the anti-tank barriers on the bridge to Russia stood calm a day later, but it cannot be expected that this will remain the case in this last outpost of the continental EU unless it holds Ukraine sufficiently after the U.S. betrayed it. To avoid being fooled, I recommend Timothy Snyder’s comments on the false peace talks and the U.S.–Ukraine balance. And to navigate further, I share the analyses packed and distilled below.
Moreover, there is a little Banned Books Museum in Tallinn, one devoted to reminding and defying the old tactic of those who can't handle freedom. And there are always means of disseminating forbidden ideas anyway and to uplifting ends as recounted by two stirring stories from the Eastern Bloc down below too.
New
Europe's Coming Fall
on one pride preceding the fall, harsh and summative
• 25 min
• Yascha Mounk
T&P: Europe must admit that it lives in a delusion: it is not influential enough, it is not safe, and there is nothing surprising about it. There is no way back to status quo ante, no possibility to procrastinate back into the stability paid for by the U.S., but only a chance to take leadership and serious action – or to fall under the rule of others.
The Path to American Authoritarianism
on competitive authoritarianism, firm and grim
• 40 min
• Lucan Way, Steven Levitsky
• Foreign Affairs
T&P: The U.S. is heading towards competitive authoritarianism, a regime where parties compete in elections that are real but unfair. In such systems, civil servants are replaced by loyalists who investigate opponents for offences such as tax evasion, not to imprison but to bully them. Once they are forced to defend themselves, their lives get disrupted and stressed – and once enough of them give up, they can be defeated again. But courts, states, and midterms are still in the game, Trump's approval rate is under 50% and Americans are better equipped for resistence than people in poorer countries. They just need to hold on.
One Word Describes Trump
on patrimonialism, informed and surgical
• 23 min
• Jonathan Rauch
• The Atlantic
T&P: The new U.S. regime is best described not as authoritarianism, autocracy, nor oligarchy, but as patrimonialism. This style of governing contests not democracy, but bureaucratic proceduralism and replaces it with informal lines to the ruler. That is also its fatal weakness, resulting in incompetence and corruption – the sin that annoys the public the most.
The Oligarchs Who Came to Regret Supporting Hitler
on the role of business, historic and unfamiliar
• 25 min
• Timothy W. Ryback
• The Atlantic
T&P: Leading German businessmen financed the Nazi coup, built concentration camps, and profited from them. Many ended up in them. Some were sentenced for crimes against humanity. Others continued to enjoy their wealth unpunished.
New, on Banned Books
‘It allowed us to survive, to not go mad’: the CIA book smuggling operation that helped bring down communism
on the liberating power of literature, thrilling and admirable
• 28 min
• Charlie English
• The Guardian
T&P: The distribution of banned books played a crucial role in the fall of communism. It was deliberately supported by the CIA, but especially by dissidents like Mirosław Chojecki, who, despite tortured, never stopped publishing Orwell or Miłosz.
The underground university
on the small freedom delivery, autobiographical and human
• 24 min
• Cheryl Misak
• Aeon
T&P: Western scholars secretly traveled to the Eastern Bloc to bring a breath of hope to fellow academics.
#40 • 17 February 2025
The major lesson of history isn’t any particular recurring pattern, but how quickly what seemed unimaginable can materialize. In its shift towards an illiberal autocracy, the U.S. is going after its people. Just look at what Trump has not only declared, but already done:
- He tried to abolish citizenship for non-citizen children, canceled initiatives aimed at diversity, equality and inclusion, even barred them from federal museums, banned non-binary identity and removed protections from LGBTQ+ students.
- He banned government agencies from communicating, shut down thousands of their websites, dismantled some of them, and stopped grants for science.
- He fired anti-corruption inspectors and dismantled oversight bodies, fired prosecutors, officials and agents who worked on investigating him or the attackers on the Capitol, who he released from prison, stripped opponents of their security clearances and police protection, and filled the leadership of the military, police and intelligence with dangerous loyalists.
- He ordered officials to report disloyal colleagues, sent 2 million of them an ultimatum to resign, and forced candidates for national security roles to declare who won the 2020 elections or who were the ‘real patriots’ of the following Capitol attack.
- He ordered the federal payroll data of all residents to be given to Elon Musk, punished and fired those who prevented it, and shielded operations of Musk’s anonymous men, who penetrate, exploit and endanger government departments, in secret.
- He ordered schools to teach ‘patriotically’, banned them from discussing racial issues under threat of defunding, and ordered universities to monitor and report foreign students who criticize Israel.
These are standard moves towards unfreedom. Much of them is illegal, but unchallenged by the Congress and pushed to outdistance courts, it makes us see the world's major democracy fall. This decay has been analysed in the most informative essays packed here the last time and again anew since. Many recent texts prove redundant, but fresh perspectives emerge. Insightful are looks into Musk’s incursion and its hazard, concepts of competitive authoritarianism and algorithmic cage or summary on how to approach it all – but the sharpest strikes comes from Ezra Klein and Timothy Snyder, packed just below.
I would not pay so much attention to this story, had it not been so cautionary and indeed consequential for the world. In the cocktail of the ongoing disruption, aggression, and their license for more to come elsewhere, primarily over Ukraine, it’s hard not to be afraid of a war engulfing Europe – or worse, oppression in exchange for peace. Again by Snyder down there (and notably here and here too) from the just-concluded Munich Security Conference, followed by Keir Giles on the major factors to consider, the world is heading towards disaster – one that could still be prevented by means proposed hereabouts:
New
Don’t Believe Him
on power psychology, calming and powerful
• ▶ 14 min
• Ezra Klein
• The New York Times
T&P: Flooding the zone with menacing orders isn’t just a strategy to overwhelm, but even more to look almighty, to sow despair and hide how weak Trump actually is. He isn’t equipped with unlimited power, but tries to persuade us to believe he is – making it more likely to become reality. The greatest danger arises if we believe him.
The Logic of Destruction
on dismantling the rule of law, clear and empowering
• 13 min
• Timothy Snyder
• Thinking about...
T&P: Oligarchs’ plan isn’t to govern differently, but to dismantle the state into chaos they aim to exploit. ‘No choice but to have a strong man in charge’ could seem as inevitable then as their dramatic success seems so now. But nothing is inevitable if we prevent demoralisation, counter deterrence, and protest together.
Appeasement at Munich
on preventing a war, comparing and drawing
• 20 min
• Timothy Snyder
• Thinking about...
T&P: Had Czechoslovakia not surrendered to Hitler, no one would have known it prevented World World II as we know it. What we don't know actually is what has been prevented alike by Ukraine resisting Putin. We don't know where would his possible appeasement lead, but events of 1938 suggest that the stakes are high. Any truce or peace at the current positions would only make Russia stronger for a wider war.
Who will defend Europe?
on the danger of war, harsh and alarming
• 22 min
• Keir Giles
• Financial Times
T&P: The danger to Europe’s democracies today is even greater than in the late 1930s. It lies in the interplay of three crucial factors: 1. American disengagement, rising up long before Trump’s takeover; 2. Western European denialism, rising from the assumption that war is something that happens to other people; 3. Russian determination, rising to third of its budget spent on war even now regardless of consequences. ‘Looking back at the 1930s, we used to wonder how it seemed that everybody could see war coming but do nothing to stop it. Now we understand, as we see the same mistakes repeated one after another.’
Old
Critics of “Don’t Look Up” Are Missing the Entire Point
on attention capitalism, meta-critic and critic
• 26 min
• Nathan J. Robinson
• Current Affairs
T&P: Film reviews often obsess over the movie itself, ignoring the ideas it raises. Don't Look Up is about diverting attention from critical issues to shallow trivialities, and the very way critics dismiss the movie as unpleasant exemplifies this problem. However, this diversion isn't caused by (and the film isn't about) people being dumb, but by (and about) billionaires manipulating us into trusting them and the reckless pursuit of profit resulting in catastrophic consequences.
#39 • 27 January 2025
Today, I focus extensively on countering the growing assault on the liberal order around the globe, inspecting both its roots, nature and response.
Much has already been summed up here, especially in the pack #34 on the eve of the U.S. elections on its core contexts and perils, and also in the following weeks on media transformation, justification, unreliability and individualization, as well as on memento of Hitler's maneuvering into chancellorship and thereupon into dictatorial powers, and on current prospects for Europe, and
for the world.
To understand the jeopardy of the ongoing Trump reboot, I recommend new analyses and essays on integrity, authority, emergency, adaptation, reporting, ungoverning, bureaucracy, schools, universities, science, museums, media, socials, disinformation, fact-checking, conversion, reconstruction, attention, tech, corporations, threats, predation, Canada,
Greenland, Denmark, diplomacy, multilateralism, and multipartisanship, as the most informative among others, in addition to more timeless works providing us with frameworks for defending freedom and analyses of social dynamics to be improved:
New
How Tyranny Begins
on lessons from the persecuted, authentic and instructive
• ▶ 6 min
• The New York Times
T&P: Dictatorships arise in steps not seen as very serious until it's too late. It's better to fight early than to hope for a savior.
A Mindset for the Trump Era
on inspiration from dissidents, stirring and guiding
• 14 min
• Gal Beckerman
• The Atlantic
T&P: Dissidents aren't revolutionaries, but those whose ‘existential attitude’ drive them to conduct themselves like free people, finding the security-obedience bargain unacceptable for their authentic selves, and answering to their ‘blend of boldness and despair’ by their action even without the prospect of success, rather then falling into resignation.
It’s Already Different
on strategies for silencing resistance, stern and revealing
• 7 min
• David A. Graham
• The Atlantic
T&P: Trump’s steps would have prompted mass outrage in 2017, but today's response is muted. Such a difference results from desensitizing people by shocking them in advance and leaving them to see the plot actually materializing as nothing new.
The New Rasputins
on the ‘New Obscurantism’, documenting and gloomy
• 16 min
• Anne Applebaum
• The Atlantic
T&P: Anti-science mysticism is enabling autocracy by obscuring nefarious actions behind shocking nonsense and distraction.
Stress Test
on today in historical comparison, reflective and open
• 24 min
• Margaret MacMillan
• Foreign Affairs
T&P: It's unclear whether leaders shape or are shaped by larger forces. They likely divert the course of history while riding the social currents, especially as people stop trusting institutions. It's up to the extent of norms exceeding how it ends this time.
Are We Sleepwalking Into Autocracy?
on the autocratic playbook, informed and illuminating
• 10 min
• Kim Lane Scheppele, Norman Eisen
• The New York Times
T&P: Orbán dismantled Hungarian democracy through ‘flooding the zone with legal challenges designed to divide and conquer his opposition’, who really drowned in it. Kaczyński tried the same playbook in Poland, but his opponents united, won the election and blocked autocracy before it became legally entrenched. It's up to the U.S. opposition to choose its end.
Mark Zuckerberg Has a Funny Idea of What It Is to Be a Man
on maturity, simple and revealing
• 6 min
• Jamelle Bouie
• The New York Times
T&P: In a world dominated by men, the most rich and powerful of them complain about a lack of masculinity. But misogyny, dominance, exploitation, aggression, boyishness and opportunism are hardly signs of mature manhood. Responsibility is.
The Limits of the Madman Theory
on the interstate psychology, analytic and advising
• 20 min
• Roseanne McManus
• Foreign Affairs
T&P: There is a long history of the madman deterrent strategy. It rarely works.
You’re Being Alienated From Your Own Attention
on the freedom of attention, massive and firm
• 21 min
• Chris Hayes
• The Atlantic
T&P: Politics, commerce and social life is now ‘a war of all against all for attention’. Under attention capitalism, we often don't pay our attention to we want to. Yet we're not determined to suffer forever. We can create alternative markets, businesses, and institutions without our attention being captured, bought, and sold as a commodity. We can even regulate attention, as well as labor has been regulated following its previous exploitation. We can liberate our souls and flourish as full human beings.
Be Like Sisyphus
on life mindset, pessimistic and hopeful
• 12 min
• Gal Beckerman
• The Atlantic
T&P: Pessimism motivates action more than optimism. As long as things can end bad, we should embrace ‘hopeful pessimism’, stand up for our values and draw serenity from enhanced humility, integrity, and self-actualization.
How the Ivy League Broke America
on meritocracy and education, magisterial and comprehensive
• 65 min
• David Brooks
• The Atlantic
T&P: The effort to make society inclusive and meritocratic through intellect-rewarding school selection failed as affluent parents adjusted to help their children to get into elite colleges and the whole society organized itself around such a race, trapped back in ‘hereditary aristocracy of wealth’ where children and teachers abandon their passion and curiosity to get A’s from standardized tests. This order overrates intelligence while missing soft skills, creativity, or courage, creates caste system based on wealth and degree, damages elite’s psyches by omnipresent extrinsic rewards, and has provoked a populist backlash that is tearing society apart. Meritocracy needs to be reinvented, humanized and improved, aimed for people with intrinsic desire to grow, and focused on curiosity, drive, mission, social intelligence, and agility. Education must provide students with more of autonomy, group projects, coaching, and engagement, replacing single assessment with portfolios and a pluralistic opportunity structure designed to help everyone to identify, nurture and pursue their passion and make a society fairer.
Old
What if We’re the Bad Guys Here?
on the roots of public discontent, provocative and uneasy
• 12 min
• David Brooks
• The New York Times
T&P: We liberal elites tend to see ourselves as the forces of progress and enlightenment, superior to uneducated bigots. This exalted perspective prevents us from seeing the social clash from the other side and grasp that our educated class rules the world through capital reproduction disguised as meritocracy. Trump exploits this order shamefully, sure, but we create it.
#38 • 20 January 2025
New
How Hitler Dismantled a Democracy in 53 Days
on the constitutional coup, detailed and cautionary
• 33 min
• Timothy W. Ryback
• The Atlantic
T&P: The 1933 Nazi takeover was an avoidable result of zigzagging within contingency and the constitution. Once surprisingly appointed chancellor, Hitler wanted to rule without parliament, but needed its unattainable two-thirds majority to pass a law empowering him to do so. To get it, he called new elections, stressed the weaknesses in structures and processes to break resistance, and triumphantly exploited the Reichstag fire, declaring a state of emergency to silence, ban, and imprison the opponents he blamed for the blaze. Amid such turmoil, he convinced the new deputies to grant him dictatorial powers.
35 Simple Health Tips Experts Swear By
on feeling good, mixed and easy
• 17 min
• Amanda Schupak
• The New York Times
T&P: Park complains. Eat nuts in dark chocolate. Don’t read at toilet. Cut tasks. Go to bed when sleepy. Connect with people. Take breaks. Drink coffee. Shut your phone down. Schedule health checkups. Use the 10-10-10 rule. Seek movement snacks. Minimize ultraprocessed foods. Don’t get up. Be curious. Protect your ears. Don't force supplements. Implement team rituals. Don’t rinse toothpaste. Close with a secret phrase. Allow the worst ideas. Flirt. Abstain from alcohol. Stop and breathe. Make fancy ice cubes. Get fascinated. Connect within couple before sleep. Employ the deathbed test. Don’t obsess over protein. Listen to the loved songs. Exercise in intense short bursts. Let go. Talk about sex. Breath deeply. Wash your hands.
#37 • 13 January 2025
New
Biocubes
on a changing world, visual and stunning
• 15 min
• Brice Ménard, Nikita Shtarkman
T&P: All life on Earth weights 1,100 gigatonnes, with plants outweighing the rest 4 times, microbes outweighing animals 31 times, marine animals outweighing terrestrial ones 3 times, viruses outweighing humans 2 times, and humans outweighing wild mammals 10 times. Human-made mass, led by concrete, weights 1,300 gigatonnes, thus outweighing the whole biosphere. Most of this ‘technomass’ has been created during the last 30 years.
The Anti-Social Century
on relationships abandonment, investigating and unpleasant
• 44 min
• Derek Thompson
• The Atlantic
T&P: People are meeting less and less, preferring delivery over pubs, streaming over cinemas, smartphones over dates. During the past seven decades, American leisure has been privatized into self-imposed solitude at home, reorienting the economy towards ‘remote life’ and resulting in increase of anxiety, depression, animosity, and intolerance. Abandoning togetherness is rewiring civic identity, and even understanding of reality. It’s about to get even worse with AI companions, soon indistinguishable from online communication with real people. Individuals, as usual, act against their own well-being, which they would actually find in connection. As solitude has been accelerated by digital-world progress and physical-world regress, its continuation is not inevitable: togetherness can be fostered by another cascade of norms and rituals.
It’s September 2026, and the Pentagon Is Alarmed
on the main Trojan horse, advocating and warning
• 16 min
• David French
• The New York Times
T&P: TikTok is dangerous. China spy on users and actively manipulate them by its algorithms even today. In case of an attack on Taiwan, it can use it as a paralyzing weapon. It should be banned not for its dull content, but its control in hostile hands.
The Internet Is Worse Than a Brainwashing Machine
on the justification machine, informed and bad
• 18 min
• Charlie Warzel, Mike Caulfield
• The Atlantic
T&P: ‘Misinformation is powerful, not because it changes minds, but because it allows people to maintain their beliefs in light of growing evidence to the contrary.’ The Jan 6th conspiracies are only a weighty consequence of the attention economy.
How America First will transform the world in 2025
on perils ahead, analytic and exploring
• 20 min
• Gideon Rachman
• Financial Times
T&P: Instead of policing the liberal international order, revisionist U.S. is becoming its leading disruptor. There are no certainties about the new world order, but scenarios: 1. Trump bargains the spheres of influence with China and Russia, leaving allies to their fate. 2. War breaks out between the Eurasian democratic and despotic states. 3. Powers avoid direct conflict, but anarchy takes over the leaderless Earth. 4. The world keeps globalizing, leaving U.S. behind its tariff walls. 5. America First succeeds economically, internationally, and domestically, deterring aggression and resistance.
Old
Why Liberals Struggle to Defend Liberalism
on four new books, polemical and liberal
• 28 min
• Adam Gopnik
• The New Yorker
T&P: Liberalism, unlike Marxism or Catholicism with their dogmas, promotes openness. As such, it permanently faces assaults, possible only because of it and threatening it by their asymmetry. Free discussion is even so superior to any liberal plan, as compromises in strengthening liberal justice don’t compromise liberalism, but highlight its pluralism. There are no shared values within societies, only an opportunity to settle disputes over them nonviolently. Liberalism as ‘an aversion to fanaticism, a will toward the coexistence of different kinds and creeds, a readiness for reform, a belief in the public criticism of power without penalty,’ proves inconceivably fragile, but valid universally.
#36 • 30 December 2024
Three short and simple texts conclude the year.
New
The western myth of the ‘guy we can do business with’
on appeasement, appeasing and pragmatic
• 7 min
• Janan Ganesh
• Financial Times
T&P: Assad, Putin, and Gaddafi actually looked much better in their early years of power. It was reasonable to attempt to befriend them, as their paths were not yet determined. However, autocrats often degenerate over time, and it is a mistake to continue pursuing friendship with them once their cruelty evidently emerge.
Social media, brain rot and the slow death of reading
on reading, disquieting and soothing
• 8 min
• Mia Levitin
• Financial Times
T&P: It used to be common to read from novel to novel, but scrolling has hijacked our attention and feeds it with low-value content or AI-generated summaries. None of these can replace the conversation of literature. We need to get back into books.
Making friends with your past and future selves
on life, serenity and Kundera, psychological and nice
• 13 min
• Katherine Ellison
• Knowable Magazine
T&P: A sense of coherence between past, present, and future can bolster mental health, emotional resilience, responsibility, and even ethics. Writing letters to our older selves often works. Simulating their replies usually helps even more.
#35 • 25 November 2024
Today I introduce Think & Pack takeaways from the articles, providing both me and you with the knowledge distilled from them by me in order to expand our concepts of the world. Here are five insightful essays and one touching documentary to try it out.
New
The forces of chance
on chaos theory, social science and moving on, dramatic and influential
• 39 min
• Brian Klaas
• Aeon
T&P: Social dynamics are so prone to random events that they are better explained by chaos theory than by simple models. Yet ‘when given the choice between complex uncertainty and comforting – but wrong – certainty, we too often choose comfort.’ More social scientists should admit this, rethink linear regression, and examine reality anew.
Can AI review the scientific literature — and figure out what it all means?
on research synthesis, researched and synthesising
• 20 min
• Helen Pearson
• Nature
T&P: Artificial Inteligence could help with knowledge synthesis, but its abilities are so far limited to assisting with selected steps still being taken by scientists. The automated production of credible systematic reviews is very far from being achieved.
Bad News
on ‘you are the media now’, disquieting and precise
• 16 min
• Charlie Warzel
• The Atlantic
T&P: Professional media with all their editorial ethics are being outperformed by seductive posts, reels and podcasts that win the attention race to the bottom. People celebrate the feeling of being on air on their own, unaware that what seems authentic is in fact not true. Democracy suffers. No simple solution is at hand.
Hitler’s Enablers
on three books inspecting the Nazi takeover, reviewing and warning
• 36 min
• Christopher R. Browning
• The New York Review of Books
T&P: Hitler's rise was not inevitable until the very last days of January 1933 when the conservatives finally preferred him over the left, granting him the minimum deal he had been maneuvering for a long time, the chancellorship, underestimating both his willingness to employ violence and the enthusiasm with which the public would welcome it as a ‘regenerative force’ in the making of the nation. They couldn't have foreseen where ’their rejection of truth, reason, and rationality’ would lead. Trump's conservative accomplices couldn't say the same.
Trump’s victory will change America. But Europe can have a different future
on the EU–US differences, momentous and optimistic
• 21 min
• Mark Mazower
• Financial Times
T&P: Europe is better positioned to resist authoritarianism than the United States, thanks to its deadly experience with it, which has shaped both its culture and constitutions. It's capable of proving America ‘an outlier, not a precursor.’
To know a place
on a meadow, science and life, deepening and beautiful
• ▶ 11 min
• Brendan Young
• Aeon
T&P: Life, even in a single meadow, is so rich that it cannot be truly understood even over a lifetime. It's worth trying anyway.
#34 • 4 November 2024
The U.S. election is about to come, yet months or even years rather than days lay before us to know how this all ends. Reading through, four major themes to share emerge for me: (1) the perils of Trump’s possible second term, making the case against him; (2) the crisis that may follow the election at very short notice; (3) the mechanisms making Trump’s haul even possible; and (4) measures promising to challenge them and preserve the rule of law in general.
(1) Much has been said about the risks, including here on dictatorship, NATO or journalism, just to bring back the most insightful pieces, not to mention Timothy Snyders’ moving move on fear or the recent Autocracy in America series. As Peter Wehner argues in his essay and The Economist judge in its endorsement, MAGA should not only be a nightmare for liberals, but also for decent conservatives, who in its storm ceases to hold on.
(2) Though the storm is expected even if he doesn't win. Maneuvers in counting, in Congress or in the streets may prolong the fight and bring chaos – all good to be ready for, as I recommend all the links above, above others on current prospects; before moving to more permanent analysis packed below.
(3) How is it possible, asks Thomas B. Edsall, that Donald Trump has a reasonable chance of winning the presidency despite all that voters now know about him? His essay, alongside with other selected works, comes with many, often research-based ingredients for an answer. These range from positioning, polarising and language to exploitation of controlled social media as well as of outdated Electoral College voting system. Within their feedback loops Trump seems to gain popularity not despite his defects but rather for the sake of them.
(4) It’s, as we live it, hard to be fixed, but if there are such measures, then, conclusions reads, by depolarising, focusing on real-life policy, and, ultimately, by abolishment of the Electoral College, however difficult any of these may seem.
Whatever the outcome will be this time, the insights of the following texts are here to be read, shared and used to preserve democracy whenever needed. Including Oliver Burkeman on anxiety, down there.
New
A Nobel for the big big questions
on the unified theory of development, critic and funny-in-a-way
• 23 min
• Noah Smith
• Noahpinion
New, on the U.S. Election
Anti-politics is eating the West
on negative partisanship development over decades and countries, as seen in an meta-analysis, narrative and magnificent
• 44 min
• The Economist
The Real Trump Mystery
on voters, politics and ‘self-reinforcing feedback loop that rewards Trump for his incessant distortions of the truth’, evidence-based and descriptive
• 23 min
• Thomas B. Edsall
• The New York Times
What Orwell Didn’t Anticipate
on the limits of clear language, exploratory and mirroring
• 24 min
• Megan Garber
• The Atlantic
This Is What $44 Billion Buys You
on Twitter turned into X, sad and warning
• 11 min
• Charlie Warzel
• The Atlantic
The Game Theory of Democracy
on system's cohesion and erosion, summative and waiting
• 28 min
• Amanda Taub
• The New York Times Magazine
What the polls can’t tell us about America’s election
on the limits of predictions, thorough and humble
• 21 min
• Oliver Roeder
• Financial Times
The Moment of Truth
on George Washington's virtues, comparative and inspirative
• 38 min
• Tom Nichols
• The Atlantic
New, on why to keep calm anyway
How not to freak out about the US election
on the timing of stressing, restful and tonic
• 9 min
• Oliver Burkeman
• The Imperfectionist
Old, on the U.S. Election
The Authentic Appeal of the Lying Demagogue: Proclaiming the Deeper Truth about Political Illegitimacy
on running an oxymoron, contra-intuitive and smart
• 108 min
• Oliver Hahl, Minjae Kim, Ezra W. Zuckerman Sivan
• American Sociological Review
The Will of the People
on the Electoral College, harsh and true
• 20 min
• Kenneth A. Taylor
• Boston Review
#30 • 1 April 2024
New
The Strongman Fantasy
on dicatorship trap, illustrative and strong
• 10 min
• Timothy Snyder
• Thinking about...
• Substack
T&P: The idea of the strongman who gets things done is false since it always collapses the same way. Dictators’ major interest inevitably ends up dying out of prison, so they secure staying in power, dismantle the justice system and replace civil servants with loyalists. Public services consequently decline and become accessible mostly through corruption and conformity. Open market falls into oligarchy as free speech falls into police surveillance. People get poorer and confused, but seize to trust each other as they fear for their jobs, and especially for their children — who now repeat school propaganda but will be in danger once they learn the truth. Voting a strongman in is voting the choice to stop him once he fails out.
My Simple Habit for Smarter Book Reading
on overcoming blind spots through rebuttals, counterintuitive and meta
• 10 min
• Scott Young
T&P: Adopting the opinions of persuasive books is tricky. Authors try hard to defend the views they have been working on for years, and no newcomer’s critical thinking can determine the truth. The best clue comes from expert reviews and rebuttals that navigate us to the core new ideas and their validity. Reading them is indispensable and reinforces our thinking.
Who’s Afraid of Freedom?
on the fight for liberalism, reviewing and balanced
• 21 min
• Helena Rosenblatt
• Foreign Affairs
T&P: Gray blames liberalism for depicting humans as better than animals. Humanism and progress are myths and liberals only fear freedom when building protectionist states, he proclaims. Moyn rejects such fatalism, criticises liberalism’s betrayal by the philosophy of negative freedom and minimal state, resulting into neoliberalism and neoconservatism, and propose to reinvent liberalism on its original idea: ‘to create the conditions that would allow people to grow intellectually and morally’.
Controlled experiment finds no detectable citation bump from Twitter promotion
on honesty of researchers, smart and comforting
• 36 min
• Trevor A. Branch, Isabelle M. Cȏté, Solomon R. David, Joshua A. Drew, Michelle LaRue, Melissa C. Márquez, E. C. M. Parsons, D. Rabaiotti, David Shiffman, David A. Steen, Alexander L. Wild
• PLoS ONE
T&P: Promotion of selected research papers on social media in an experiment doesn't interfere into their further citations.
Old
Jimmy Wales: Wikipedia
on knowledge and its dilemmas, unbidden and inspirative
• ▶ 195 min
• Lex Fridman
• Lex Fridman Podcast
• YouTube
#29 • 11 December 2023
Today's pack is full of politics, especially those that can affect World development for decades. There are pretty Advent 24 pieces in the Atlantic's If Trump Wins special, most worth reading, but summarized in the Post essay; just except for international impacts following the weakening of NATO, laid out by Anne Applebaum in one of the Advent lineup. Dark are the prospects to face, but in the voluminous conversation of Fridman with Harari, refreshment and hope can be found as well.
New
A Trump dictatorship is increasingly inevitable. We should stop pretending.
on what to prepare for, persuasive and disturbing
• 35 min
• Robert Kagan
• The Washington Post
Trump Will Abandon NATO
on changing the World order, straight and dark
• 12 min
• Anne Applebaum
• If Trump Wins
• The Atlantic
Yuval Noah Harari: Human Nature, Intelligence, Power, and Conspiracies
on Israel, AI and meditation too, personal and inspiring
• ▶ 172 min
• Lex Fridman
• Lex Fridman Podcast
How America became the world’s Leviathan
on the Earth infrastructure control, new and unbidden
• 18 min
• Jake Dow, Stephen Paduano
• Engelsberg Ideas
#24 • 8 May 2023
When I released the last special issue on artificial intelligence, I hadn’t expected how much insightful content I would need to go through in order to complete the second portion as announced. But here I am. After finally reading the entire swelling list and eliminating all what is also pretty good, but redundant in a way, I’ve found the following 12 pieces, alongside with the 12 from last time, being the ones that stimulate my imagination about the future the most.
Thinking over artificial intelligence is nothing like only inspecting some advanced technology. This one makes us rethink intelligence itself, as well as creativity, language, humanity, and all the uncertainity ahead. The selected works offer fresh perspectives for understanding the world and outline the paths to follow to make such a world the best it can be. What's interesting is how often and urgently their authors recommend starting to take the risks of artificial intelligence much more seriously, through regulation and new institutions especially. Hopefully a little better understanding of what's going on will help.
Both parts of the special are ready here together for further sharing.
New, on Artificial Intelligence, in expectations insights
The Age of AI and Our Human Future
on what comes next, creepy and beautiful
• ▶ 24 min
• Henry Kissinger, Eric Schmidt, Daniel Huttenlocher
• YouTube
Artificial intelligence is transforming our world — it is on all of us to make sure that it goes well
on what is at stake, clean and great
• 20 min
• Max Roser
• Our World in Data
Will AIs Take All Our Jobs and End Human History—or Not? Well, It’s Complicated…
on the rules of the future, computational and ingenious
• 120 min
• Stephen Wolfram
New, on Artificial Intelligence, in perils fears
AI is about to make social media (much) more toxic
on threats and reforms needed, educated and targeted
• 29 min
• Jonathan Haid, Eric Schmidt
• The Atlantic
Will A.I. Become the New McKinsey?
on capitalism again, critique and searching
• 30 min
• Ted Chiang
• The New Yorker
Yuval Noah Harari argues that AI has hacked the operating system of human civilisation
on stories reaching our minds and hearts, anthropological and strong
• 13 min
• Yuval Noah Harari
• The Economist
Pausing AI Developments Isn't Enough. We Need to Shut it All Down
on the doomsday scenario, alarming and stern
• 15 min
• Eliezer Yudkowsky
• Time
Eliezer Yudkowsky: Dangers of AI and the End of Human Civilization
on intelligence and so on, (un)calm and deep
• ▶ 203 min
• Lex Fridman
• Lex Fridman Podcast
New, on Artificial Intelligence, in transformations
Can Intelligence Be Separated From the Body?
on physical world, slowing-down and reporting
• 14 min
• Oliver Whang
• The New York Times
The third magic
on understanding the world, comparative and bold
• 26 min
• Noah Smith
• Noahpinion
• Substack
What do experts in artificial intelligence expect for the future?
on forecasts, summarising and humble
• 13 min
• Max Roser
• Our World in Data
Everything is a remix: AI and image generation
on art, creativity and life, impressive and pathetic
• ▶ 24 min
• Kirby Ferguson
• Aeon
• YouTube
#23 • 3 April 2023
In recent months, we have been overwhelmed with texts about artificial intelligence. I allowed myself a little distance, read dozens of articles and packed the most thought-provoking ones into this thematic issue. I'm still reading other inspirational pieces, so it seems that's not all there is to enjoy. But here we go.
New, on Artificial Intelligence, in description
What Is ChatGPT Doing … and Why Does It Work?
on language models in computers, humans and the world, immersive and impressive
• 230 min
• Stephen Wolfram
Beyond ChatGPT: what chatbots mean for the future
on the impact looked out for, documentary and summarising
• ▶ 16 min
• The Economist
• YouTube
What Happens When AI Has Read Everything?
on human culture mirroring, reviewing and human
• 13 min
• Ross Andersen
• The Atlantic
New, on Artificial Intelligence, in discussion
The Data Delusion
on data versus knowledge seeking, historical and critique
• 28 min
• Jill Lepore
• The New Yorker
The Difference Between Speaking and Thinking
on chatbot’s nonsenses, distinguishing and link-full
• 11 min
• Matteo Wong
• The Atlantic
The False Promise of ChatGPT
on thinking, analytic and tough
• 23 min
• Noam Chomsky, Ian Roberts, Jeffrey Watumull
• The New York Times
The stupidity of AI
on intelligence and responsibility, wide and stern
• 38 min
• James Bridle
• The Guardian
ChatGPT Has Impostor Syndrome
on one blind spot, recursive and encouraging
• 11 min
• Ross Andersen
• The Atlantic
New, on Artificial Intelligence, in horizons
What ChatGPT and generative AI mean for science
on science industry, surmising and normative
• 30 min
• Chris Stokel-Walker, Richard Van Noorden
• Nature
The Imminent Danger of A.I. Is One We’re Not Talking About
on capitalism, reminding and seeking
• 12 min
• Ezra Klein
• The New York Times
AI & Human Interaction
on consciousness, inspecting and navigating
• 24 min
• Miriam Gorr
• Philosophy Now
Why Write?
on what remains, clear and simple
• 3 min
• Farnam Street
#13 • 31 October 2022
I've found Thinkerpack, auto-generated from what I select, indeed little bit unpersonal – thus from time to time, I'm about to add few words to greet you. I try to pick the best out of dozens of articles I choose and read from my favorite newsletters, but in the last two weeks, the inviting content seemed so endless that I had to slow down to put this double-issue finally together. Here is a special twosome on climate future, disproofs of popular theories and so much more to learn. I hope you'll enyoy it as much as I still do.
New
The New World: Envisioning Life After Climate Change
on future, visual and inescapable
• 36 min
• David Wallace-Wells
• The New York Times Magazine
Beyond Catastrophe: A New Climate Reality Is Coming Into View
on solutions, illuminating and powerful
• 42 min
• David Wallace-Wells
• The New York Times Magazine
Generations, We Hardly Knew Ye: An Obituary
on a concept so popular, tough and necessary
• 12 min
• Cort W. Rudolph, Hannes Zacher
• Group & Organization Management
There Are No ‘Five Stages’ of Grief
on searching for reassurance beyond theory, reviewing and real-life
• 20 min
• Hilda Bastian
• The Atlantic
Political Ideology in Early Childhood: Making the Case for Studying Young Children in Political Psychology
on shaping our believes, brilliant and big
• 84 min
• Michal Reifen-Tagar, Andrei Cimpian
• Political Psychology
The World According to Xi Jinping
on true believers of China and the West, informative and straight
• 35 min
• Kevin Rudd
• Foreign Affairs
How to change your self-limiting beliefs
on what holds us back, self-exploring and uplifling
• 24 min
• Rebecca Roache
• Psyche
#9 • 26 September 2022
New
Tech futurism's blind spot
on a fairytale facing reality, awakening and calling
• 24 min
• Dave Karpf
• The Future, Now and Then
How to Build a Life, Live with Arthur Brooks and Daniel Pink
on suffering and toxic positivity, hard and empowering
• ▶ 47 min
• Arthur C. Brooks, Daniel H. Pink
• The Atlantic Festival
• YouTube
The Making of Modern Ukraine, Class 1 & on
on understanding history, engaging and energizing
• ▶ 46 min
• Timothy Snyder
• Yale University
• YouTube
Belief in a Dangerous World Does Not Explain Substantial Variance in Political Attitudes, But Other World Beliefs Do
on what matters, revising and surprising-in-a-way
• 48 min
• Jeremy D. W. Clifton, Nicholas Kerry
• Social Psychological and Personality Science
Old
This Is Your Brain on Silence
on peace of mind, quiet and soothing
• 20 min
• Daniel A. Gross
• Nautilus
#4 • 22 August 2022
New
Honesty Is Love
on truth and love, kind and liberating
• 11 min
• Arthur C. Brooks
• The Atlantic
Reckoning With Memories of Budapest
on city and time, visual and engaging
• 41 min
• Stephen Hiltner
• The New York Times
People around the world have gained democratic rights, but some have many more rights than others
on democracy across time and space, graphic and easy
• 16 min
• Bastian Herre
• Our World in Data
International treaties have mostly failed to produce their intended effects
on what seems not to work well, exploratory and unpleasant
• 33 min
• PNAS
A Last Act of Intimate Kindness
on live and death, personal and touching
• 10 min
• Michelle Friedman
• The New York Times
New, on Longtermism
How Future Generations Will Remember Us
on suffering, confronting and uncompromising
• 11 min
• William MacAskill
• The Atlantic
Against Jackpot-Longtermism
on people's needs and humility, critical and realistic
• 26 min
• Dave Karpf
• The Future, Now and Then
The New Moral Mathematics
on the book that makes hype, reviewing and rethinking
• 36 min
• Kieran Setiya
• Boston Review
Old
Neuroscientist Explains Memory in 5 Levels of Difficulty
on how brain and conversation work, playful and amazing
• ▶ 30 min
• Daphna Shohamy
• Wired
• YouTube
#3 • 15 August 2022
New
Abolish life sentences
on justice and humanity, visionary and alerting
• 32 min
• Judith Lichtenberg
• Aeon
To Get Out of Your Head, Get Out of Your House
on being within nature, calm and true
• 9 min
• Arthur C. Brooks
• The Atlantic
What Matters More in Decisions: Analysis or Process?
on decision making, simple and contra-intuitive
• 7 min
• Farnam Street
I Tried Slow Reading For 60 Days Straight — This is What Happened
on what should be clear but isn’t, calm and easy
• 8 min
• Akshad Singi
• Better Humans
• Medium
New, on Power
What the Mighty Miss
on rules and the blind spots of power, analysing and critic
• 30 min
• Ngaire Woods
• What Is Power? (02)
• Foreign Affairs
The Perils of Pessimism
on national anxiety consequences, comparative and optimistic-in-a-way
• 27 min
• Daniel W. Drezner
• What Is Power? (03)
• Foreign Affairs
Hierarchies of Weakness
on social division’s connection to power, integrative and highlighting
• 25 min
• Amitav Acharya
• What Is Power? (07)
• Foreign Affairs
Old
How to stop overthinking
on what a mind peace can be called, therapeutic and handy
• 34 min
• Pia Callesen
• Psyche
#2 • 8 August 2022
New
The Case for Longtermism
on ethics of human civilisation, thoughtful and thoroughgoing
• 16 min
• William MacAskill
• The New York Times
How Universal Are Our Emotions?
on feeling across languages, immersive and uplifting
• 27 min
• Nikhil Krishnan
• The New Yorker
Can Russia Divide Europe?
on the lure of false peace, farsighted and warning
• 20 min
• Nathalie Tocci
• Foreign Affairs
How Your Brain Fills in the Blanks with Experience
on shaping mind and its results, straightforward and instructive
• 18 min
• Chantel Prat
• Nautilus
Why the Old Elite Spend So Much Time at Work
on a shift in our lives, informative and interesting
• 18 min
• Derek Thompson
• The Atlantic
Vast New Study Shows a Key to Reducing Poverty: More Friendships Between Rich and Poor
on social capital, important and big
• 27 min
• Claire Cain Miller, Josh Katz, Aatish Bhatia
• The New York Times
• Nature
What lies beneath government
on the power of relationships, soothing and inspirational
• 31 min
• Gordon Peake, Miranda Forsyth
• Aeon
Last Best Hope
on making up G-12 towards global cooperation, bold and sober
• 32 min
• Ivo H. Daalder, James M. Lindsay
• Foreign Affairs
Old
The power of feedback
on learning, most-cited and powerful
• 97 min
• John Hattie, Helen Timperley
• Review of Educational Research
T&P: Feedback is one of the most powerful engines of learning. It is effective when directly related to learning goals and addressing where one is going, how he or she is going, and where to go next. It is most beneficial when focussing on processing the task and on self-regulation while useful when focusing on the task itself only when providing specific correction and useless or even harmful when assessing the person as such.